Log in

No account? Create an account
28 November 2010 @ 02:19 pm
The Forever Reading  
I've been trying to work my way through all of the Hugo- and Nebula-award-winning novels I haven't yet read (which are legion), in between reading new short fiction etc.

Yesterday I got to Joe Haldeman's The Forever War. Yes, I know it's shocking and shameful for an SF buff, not to mention an SF writer, not to mention someone who's fascinated by time dilation, not to have read that book. I haven't read Anna Karenina either.

So I started it yesterday . . . and realized that I'd already read it.

Or rather, I'd already read the first chapter. Or, to be very precise, I'd read the story "Hero," which appeared in the June, 1972 issue of Analog, and which became "Private Mandella" in TFW.

I read that story when it first came out (I googled the cover of the June, 1972 Analog and I remember that picture clearly). There were only a few details that stuck with me from the story I read back then: the woman being decapitated by a flying rock while fleeing the site of an explosion; the casual sleeping/sexual arrangements among the soldiers; the "french corkscrew."

(Give me a break. I was a 12-year-old boy. The lurid and the sexy were naturally the most interesting things to me.) (Now that I think of it, the "confraternization" in the novel looks like it was designed by a 12-year-old boy. I've never read a feminist critique of TFW, but I can just imagine it. Female soldiers who are "compliant and promiscuous" by law?? Oh, my aching head!)

My memory has garbled practically everything else. I remembered the training as taking place on Luna, not on Charon, and I remembered the decapitated soldier as being the protagonist's bedmate, and I didn't remember any interstellar war. There was something vaguely familiar about the telepathic green teddy bears on Epsilon Aurigae Alpha, but I'm not sure I actually read about them in 1972.

On eBay my handle is "piecesofmypast", because I am forever trying to locate tidbits I remember from childhood. How odd to come upon one unawares.
Current Location: Nearing the solstice
Current Mood: thoughtfulthoughtful
Current Music: El Condor Pasa
girlspell: cleaning an icongirlspell on November 28th, 2010 09:54 pm (UTC)
Strange coming across something you had read so young under a different title. I doubt the change of title improved the story. Funny about forever wars. They keep on going till they are in danger of running out of men (as with the 100 years war) These kind of wars are everywhere, starting from the close of the 100 years war on to present day war on terror. Oh you still had the "grand show" war which was set for five or six years (really eleven years WWII was the continuation of WWI and congratulate each other on it's end. Still in the background it continues. They'll keep on going (like the war on terror) till one side runs out of men. Then they will have a phony truce till the little boys reach 12 and will start all over again. I just don't like a sci fi spin on it. The premise is too real. The sex sounds as contrived as the "promiscuous" by law deal. I would think the government is more interested in how efficient your body is killing another person. It's the whole point. Although to be fair, the Spartans used homosexual sex during war to control the Soldiers loyalty. Probably where the author got the idea.